• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Big Flavors from a Tiny Kitchen
menu icon
go to homepage
  • Recipes
  • About
  • Events
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • subscribe
    search icon
    Homepage link
    • Recipes
    • About
    • Events
    • Contact
    • Subscribe
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • ×
    Home » Recipes » Dessert Recipes

    First Birthday Party: Colorful Elmo Cupcakes (Amy Sedaris' Vanilla Cupcakes w Vanilla Buttercream Frosting)

    Modified: Mar 7, 2017 · Published: Nov 22, 2012 by Ashley

    • Facebook
    • Email
    • Flip
    • Threads
    • Bluesky

    This post may contain affiliate links, which won’t change your price but will share some commission.

    This Thanksgiving was extra special because it was my son's first birthday. Wow. A year already!! I didn't want to let the fact that it was Thanksgiving deter me from baking a special cake just for him to go to town on. I wanted a simple cupcake recipe that I could take part of to make into a little cake so that we could all enjoy it.

    First Birthday Party: Colorful Elmo Cupcakes

    I wanted to make it a little more fun by making them colorful, so after I portioned out the batter, I put drops of food coloring onto each and swirled it around with a toothpick. It was way easier than doing a bunch of colored batches of batter, and it gave them a really cool tie-dyed effect. Here's what they looked like before I baked them...

    First Birthday Party: Colorful Elmo Cupcakes

    ...and after they came out of the oven.

    First Birthday Party: Colorful Elmo Cupcakes

    I cooled them overnight and frosted them all on Thanksgiving morning. They were super moist, and the buttercream was delicious. The frosting did cover up the tie-dye, but you could still see it peeking out a bit. I'd definitely make these again.

    Amy Sedaris's Vanilla Cupcakes
    I Like You: Hospitality Under the Influence - Amy Sedaris

    yield: Makes 24 cupcakes

    1 ½ sticks unsalted butter
    1 ½ cups sugar
    2 eggs
    2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract
    2 ½ teaspoons baking powder
    ¼ teaspoon salt
    2 ½ cups flour
    1 ¼ cups milk

    Turn oven on to 375 degrees F.

    Put butter in mixer and beat at medium speed until somewhat smooth. Pour in sugar and beat well. Add 2 eggs. I like to crack the eggs on the side of the bowl while it is moving, which can be really stupid. I like to take chances. Yes, I have had to throw away my batter because I lost eggshells in the mix. Yes, it was a waste of food and yes, I know how expensive butter is, but what can I say? I'm a daredevil. Mix well. Add: vanilla, baking powder, salt, flour, and milk. Beat until it looks like it is supposed to and pour into individual baking cups, until they are about ⅔ full. Bake for 20 minutes or until golden brown. Should produce 24 cupcakes; I get 18 because I'm doing something wrong, although my cupcakes were voted second best in the city by New York Magazine.

    Frost with Amy Sedaris's Vanilla Buttercream Frosting.

    Here's the mini two layer cake that I ended up making with the remaining batter. I lucked out that I picked a recipe that made 24 cupcakes - I made 12 and used the rest of the batter for the cake. I made 4 different colors of frosting, and they unintentionally turned out perfect for the Elmo/Sesame Street themed party!

    First Birthday Party: Colorful Elmo Cupcakes

    Amy Sedaris's Vanilla Buttercream Frosting
    I Like You: Hospitality Under the Influence - Amy Sedaris

    yield: Makes enough for 24 cupcakes

    1 box confectioners' sugar
    1 stick unsalted butter
    1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract*
    ¼ cup milk or light cream
    food coloring (optional)

    *Less than 1 teaspoon pure almond extract can be substituted.

    In a bowl combine: one box of confectioners' sugar, one stick of unsalted butter, one teaspoon of pure vanilla extract, and ¼ cup of milk or light cream and beat for a while. Really whip it, don't be afraid to get in there. I occasionally add food coloring and sometimes substitute pure almond extract for vanilla.
    If you do choose to add pure almond extract instead of vanilla, you're on your own. I don't know the measurement for it, but I do know it's less than the amount of vanilla you would add.

    Big Flavors Rating: 5 Stars

    I think the birthday boy enjoyed it 😉

    First Birthday Party: Colorful Elmo Cupcakes

    More Dessert Recipes

    • Espresso chocolate chip brownies on a serving tray.
      Espresso Chocolate Chip Brownies {Starbucks Copycat}
    • Maple cookies on plates with a pitcher of maple syrup alongside.
      Maple Cookies
    • Peppermint mocha in a mug garnished with chocolate and peppermint candies.
      Homemade Peppermint Whipped Cream
    • Homemade tiramisu in a serving dish with plates and forks for serving.
      Best Classic Italian Tiramisu

    Reader Interactions

    Comments

    No Comments

    Leave a comment Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Primary Sidebar

    Hi, I'm Ashley and I’ve been writing about food & recipes here at Big Flavors from a Tiny Kitchen since 2006. I want to help you (yes, you!) gain confidence in the kitchen so you are excited to cook at home for yourself and your loved ones.

    More about me →

    Favorite Spring Recipes

    • Mayo-free Deviled Eggs
    • Middle Eastern Fattoush Salad with Homemade Pita Chips
    • Birthday Cake Confetti Pancakes with Sprinkles
    • Italian Cream Cheese and Ricotta Cheesecake
    • Garlicky Mushroom Ricotta Pizza with Wild Arugula + Aged Balsamic
    • Slow Cooker "Roasted" Beets
    • Honey Balsamic Roasted Carrots
    • Italian Ricotta Cookies
    • Rhubarb Custard Pie
    • Easy Instant Pot Herbed Potato Salad

    Mother's Day + Easter Brunch

    • Epic Brunch Board on a Budget
    • Baby Spinach and Cheddar Quiche Made with Fresh Spinach
    • Turkey Salad Tea Sandwiches with Dried Cherries
    • Great Grandma Maria Francesca Cardile's Italian Easter Cookies
    • Brie Waffle Bites
    • Challah French Toast
    • Creamsicle Smoothies
    • DM Bloody Mary
    • Turkey Scotch Eggs
    • The Herbalist

    Popular Now

    • Overhead view of spinach and cheddar quiche with forks.
      Baby Spinach and Cheddar Quiche Made with Fresh Spinach
    • Close up of a few cucumber slices topped with a spiced chickpea purée.
      Falafel-Spiced Cucumber Bites
    • Overhead shot of a plate with rectangles of white coconut jelly.
      Coconut Jelly
    • Falafel in pita bread with toppings served with yogurt-herb sauce.
      Falafel with Yogurt-Herb Sauce
    • Overhead view of assorted breakfast items displayed on a board.
      Epic Brunch Board on a Budget
    • No Mayo Deviled Eggs: Skip the mayo in this appetizer favorite - guaranteed to be a hit at any party!
      No Mayo Deviled Eggs

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    About

    • About Ashley
    • Press + Recognition
    • Events
    • Virtual Cooking Classes
    • Podcast
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy

    Newsletter

    • Sign up to receive delicious recipes and exclusive content right to your inbox!

    As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no added cost to you.

    ©2006–2025  BIG FLAVORS FROM A TINY KITCHEN LLC | ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

    *Third-party advertisers may collect or use non-personally identifiable information to serve you more relevant ads.